BEST GYRO
2022
BEST HEALTHY EATERY
BESTOFLONGISLAND.COM • VOTERS GUIDE • BETHPAGE BEST OF LONG ISLAND 2022 43
HOT DOGS
American Roadside Burgers–
Smithtown
Ben’s Kosher Delicatessen Restaurant
& Caterers
Bethpage Ballpark (Long Island
Ducks)
Bonanza Stand of Oyster Bay
Charlie’s Legendary Hot Dogs
Checkers
Knot of This World Pretzels
Nathan’s Famous, Inc.
Rudi’s Bar and Grill
Salvatore’s of Elmont Pizzeria &
Restaurant
Sandy and Jeanie
Shake Shack–Westbury
Slider Joe’s
Sonic Drive-In–North Babylon
Star Island Grill
The Pit Stop–Merrick
ICE CREAM
Cloud Nine Ice Cream & Cereal Bar
Cold Stone Creamery
Douglas & James Homemade Ice
Cream (Sweet Treats on the Wharf)
Fit by Globish
Five Pennies Creamery
Gemelli Gelato
Hershey’s–West Islip
Ice Cream Social
Il Corso Pastry Shop
Krisch’s Restaurant & Ice Cream
Parlour
Lics Ice Cream
McNulty’s Ice Cream
Moolala
Old Fashioned Ice Cream
Once Upon a Sundae
Scoops Ice Cream
Skipperdee’s
Swirlz World
JARRED PASTA SAUCE
Caroline’s Pushcart Onions
Cerillo’s Williston Park–Williston Park
Domenico’s–Levittown
Emilio’s–Commack
Fork & Cleaver/ Meat Sauce–New
Hyde Park
Iavarone Bros.
Mamma Lombardi’s–Holbrook
Maroni Cuisine–Northport
Prince Umberto of Franklin Square
Razzano’s–Glen Cove
Trader Joe’s Organic Tomato Basil–
Multiple Locations
Uncle Giuseppe’s–Multiple Locations
Vincent’s Clam Bar
LOBSTER ROLL
Atlantic Seafood
Claws Seafood Market
Clubhouse Long Island
Finley’s Seafood
Harbor Crab Co.
Jordan’s Lobster Farm
Kerber’s Farm
Lobster Roll AKA Lunch
Love Lane Kitchen
Maldon & Mignonette
Popei’s Clam Bar–Coram
Spiro’s
Star Island Grill
The Gourmet Whaler
The Rex Burger & Lobster
Whiskey Down Diner
LUNCH DEAL
Ben’s Kosher Delicatessen Restaurant
& Caterers
BrickHouse Brewery & Restaurant
Buttermilk’s Kitchen
CJ’s Coffee Shop
Dos MexiCuban Cantina
George White
Hilltop Bagel Cafe
Jeco’s Deli
Lindenhurst Diner
Mac’s Countryside Deli & Catering
Panera Bread
Rudi’s Bar and Grill
Sea Basin Restaurant
Skipperdee’s
Star Island Grill
The Food Mill
Vito’s Ristorante & Pizzeria
LUNCHEONETTE
Brigitte’s Bayville Luncheonette–
Bayville
Bun & Burger–West Hampton
CJ’s Coffee Shop
Eastport Luncheonette
Flo’s Luncheonette
George’s Luncheonette–Patchogue
Great Neck Diner
Hildebrandt’s–Williston Park
House of Donuts
Krisch’s Restaurant & Ice Cream
Parlour
Laurel Diner–Long Beach
Little Nook Cafe
Maureen’s Kitchen
Northport Sweet Shop
Skipperdee’s
MACARONI AND CHEESE
Biscuits & Barbeque–Mineola
Blind Bat Brewery Bistro
Bobby Q’s
Brewology295–Eastport
Brugman’s Deli
Cheezly’s
Chef Elvis Caribbean Cuisine
Dix Hills Diner
Harbor Crab Co.
Karvers Grille
Mac & Melts
Maliblue Oyster Bar–Lido Beach
Mercato Kitchen & Cocktails
Off The Block Kitchen & Meats
Panera Bread–Multiple Locations
Pigs on a Wing
Spiro’s
Zorn’s of Bethpage
MEATBALL
Angelina’s Italian Cuisine
Fattusco’s Gourmet
Grandpa Tony’s
Joe’s Pizza and Pasta
Mama Lombardi’s–Holbrook
Mario’s Pizza
Pizzatini
Prato 850–Commack
Robkes Country Inn
Salisbury Tavern Sports Bar & Grill
Salvatore’s of Elmont
Spiro’s
That Meetball Place
The Famous Meatballers
Vespa Italian Kitchen & Bar
Vincent’s Clam Bar–Westbury
Vito’s Ristorante & Pizzeria
MILKSHAKE
Brugman’s Deli
Claude’s Restaurant
Cloud Nine Ice Cream & Cereal Bar
Diner By The Sea
Douglas & James Homemade Ice
Cream (Sweat Treats on the Wharf)
Lics Ice Cream
Lindenhurst Diner
Shake Shack
Spoons Ice Cream & Cereal Bar
Waffle Magic
MUSSELS
Claws Seafood Market
Croxley’s Ale House–Multiple
Locations
Gallery Four
Grandpa Tony’s
H2O Seafood Grill–Smithtown
Harbor Crab Company–Patchogue
Hooks & Chops
Lobster Roll
Louie’s Grille and Liquors
Nicky’s of Centerport
Popei’s Clam Bar–Bethpage
Popei’s Clam Bar–Coram
Salvatore’s of Elmont
Sea Basin Restaurant
Spiro’s
Vito’s Ristorante & Pizzeria
Waterzooi Belgian Bistro & Oyster
Bar
Wild Honey on Main–Port
Washington
NACHOS
Applebee’s–Multiple Locations
Buffalo Wild Wings–Multiple
Locations
Del Fuego–Saint James
Dirty Taco and Tequila
Drift Inn
El Coyote Loco
K. Pacho–New Hyde Park
Maracas Southwest Grill
Miller’s Ale House–Multiple Locations
Novi Restaurant, Nacho Italiano–
Baldwin
Restoration Kitchen & Cocktails
Smok Haus
The Metropolitan Restaurant & Bar
The Refuge
Three Amigo’s–East Northport
Tocolo Cantina
Uptown Taco
OFF PREMISE CATERER
Bayville Deli & Pizzeria
Ben’s Kosher Delicatessen Restaurant
& Caterers
BrickHouse Brewery & Restaurant
Chara’s Kitchen and Catering
Chubs Meats
Delicious Moments Caterers
Farm to Table Catering and Cafe by
Filomena
Gemelli Gourmet Market North
Gourmelos Mediterranean Market
Hunki’s–West Hempstead
Joe’s Gourmet Meats
Kim Stahl K-2-Catering
One Three Catering
Philip Stone Caterers
Prince Umberto of Franklin Square
Robbins Wolfe Eventeurs
Seaqua Delicatessen and Caterers
Sempre Fame Gourmet Grill & BBQ
Catering
Wonton Palooza
VOTE FOR US
HUMMUS MEDITERRANEAN
HOLBROOK
1066 Main St.
11741 Holbrook
(631) 615 2202
HUMMUS MEDITERRANEAN
SELDEN
680 Middle Country Rd
11780 Selden
(631) 846 8165
FOOD
/BESTOFLONGISLAND.COM
