BESTOFLONGISLAND.COM WINNERS GUIDE BETHPAGE BEST OF LONG ISLAND 2021 35
BEST HEALTH FOOD
STORE
TRADER JOE’S
Multiple Locations
traderjoes.com
Over the years, Long Island residents have
flocked to Trader Joe’s to stock up on their
health food needs. The store aims to bring
high quality products at the best every day
prices, and that remains just as true for the
health food items available as well. From ready
to make meals to snacks and treats, Trader
Joe’s has a variety of options for those who are
more health-focused but don’t want to miss
out on some delicious food. The store also has
options for those with dietary restrictions,
including gluten free, kosher and vegan, so no
one has to miss out on the healthy snacks and
meals available.
BEST HEALTHY EATERY
HUMMUS MEDITERRANEAN
1066 Main St, Holbrook
(631) 615-2202 www.hummusny.com
Rice bowl, salad bowl or pita and stuff it with
falafel, chicken kebab, grilled shrimp among
fresh and healthy ingredients produces a
delicious and hearty meal or take home
hummus and pita chips. Hearty and delicious
food here will be a certain hit with your family
or go in and enjoy the varied specialites -
there’s a small eating area to enjoy it on site.
An eggplant salad is amazing so try it or check
into a meal plan service if you want to switch
to clean eating and make these Mediteranean
dishes your regular diet. The staff is friendly
so don’t be shy to ask about the cuisine. The
menu is extensive. Food ordered here is always
fresh and healthy!
BEST HEALTHY EATERY
PANERA BREAD
Multiple Locations
panerabread.com
Experience food as it should be at Panera
Bread. Since opening in 1980, Panera has
grown from a small cookie shop in Boston
to a nation-wide chain with more than 2300
locations throughout the United States and
Canada. The health-conscious eatery is
dedicated to serving clean food — meaning
no artificial preservatives, sweeteners, flavors
and no colors from artificial sources. Its
meals are sourced from animals that are
raised humanely, sustainably and without
the use of antibiotics. From tasty sandwiches
and nourishing grain bowls to hearty soups
and nutritious salads, there’s a tasty meal
waiting for everyone. And, of course, no trip is
complete without a freshly-baked pastry! Stop
into Panera bread for food you can truly feel
good about!
BEST HOMEMADE
PASTA
UNCLE GIUSEPPE’S
Multiple Locations
uncleg.com
What’s the next best thing to making your own
pasta at home? Not sure? Uncle Giuseppe’s
has the answer that’ll make life easier for you
in the kitchen. Uncle Giuseppe’s is known for
its famous viewing rooms where pasta and
mozzarella are made fresh daily. Each location
offers a full-service supermarket experience
where you can do your grocery shopping
while waiting for your fresh pasta to be ready
to be taken home. Whether you’re getting
ravioli, gnocchi, or something else, you can be
rest assured that you’re getting the ultimate
shopping experience and old-world service you
can’t find anywhere else on the island!
BEST HOT DOGS
NATHAN’S FAMOUS, INC.
Multiple Locations
nathansfamous.com
There’s a reason why Nathan’s Famous
has the best hot dogs in town. Since 1916,
Nathan’s has been serving up its classic hot
dogs, causing hungry Long Islanders to flock
to their shops for a quick bite to eat. While
the eatery started off with your standard hot
dog, Nathan’s has since stepped up its game
and added chili and cheese into the mix,
making it the ultimate lunch or dinner for
the Long Islander on the go. While the menu
has expanded to include burgers and chicken
as well, nothing beats a Nathan’s hot dog —
there’s a reason why the eatery’s hot dog has
stood the test of time.
BEST ICE CREAM
DOUGLAS & JAMES HOMEMADE ICE
CREAM (SWEET TREATS ON THE WHARF)
405 Main St, Port Washington
(516) 708-1706
Located on the water’s edge, Sweet Treats
on the Wharf, is the perfect stop for a hot
summer day either by car or bike. There is
ample parking for both and afterwards you can
even take a nice walk down the boardwalk to
take in all that Port Washington has to offer.
Sweet Treats makes all of their ice cream on
site every day so you can be sure that you
are getting a premium treat when you visit.
This ice cream shop offers sugar free, kosher,
lactose free and gluten free options so there is
something for everyone in the family. Head on
down to their Port Washington location once
the summer hits for an unforgettable treat.
BEST JARRED PASTA
SAUCE
VINCENT’S CLAM BAR
179 Old Country Rd, Carle Place
(516) 742-4577 www.vincentsclambar.
com
A pasta dish wouldn’t be the comfort food
that it is without a sauce that satisfies your
taste buds. Vincent’s Clam Bar prides itself on
making a sauce that’s “even better than Mama
used to make”. The possibilities are endless
with its jarred homemade sauce. The eatery
carries vodka sauce, tomato and its awardwinning
marinara which was selected as the
best sauce by Consumer Reports. You don’t
have to visit the restaurant in Carle Place to try
its sauce. Visit the Vincent’s Clam Bar website
to purchase a 12-pack of the flavor of your
choice. Enjoy a little piece of authentic Italian
cuisine from the comfort of your home today!
BEST LOBSTER ROLL
THE LOBSTER ROLL AKA LUNCH
1980 Montauk Hwy, Amagansett
(631) 267-3740 www.lobsterroll.com
Since 1965, Lobster Roll, affectionately called
LUNCH, has been serving the people of Long
Island the best lobster they can find. Known far
and wide for its lobster rolls, the simply-named
eatery has been a seafood hot-spot since day one.
Locals know it’s the only place to get a great bite
of fresh, chewey lobster on a soft, buttery roll.
What could possibly be more amazing than that
on a hot, summer day? This retro shack brings
people back and welcomes everyone with a
smile, continuing to serve extraordinary dishes
that are unmatched in presentation and taste.
Take one bite and you’ll never want to order a
lobster roll anywhere else!
BEST LUNCH DEAL
HILLTOP BAGEL CAFE
623 Horseblock Rd, Farmingville
(631) 846-1828 www.hilltopbagelcafe.com
Great bagels and people along with
absolutely incredible food like a popular
bacon egg and cheese sandwich: this
describes Hilltop Bagel Cafe — a place you’ll
be glad to know. Breakfast appetites here
are met with pancakes, french fries, home
fries and omelettes. A varied menu has
plenty more items, from wraps, heroes and
burgers to chopped salads and more. If you
love being served by friendly people, this
neighborhood spot, which draws favor of
hungry locals and high schoolers, should be
your go-to. Interesting flavors among cream
cheese and great people actually draw the
attention of people from NYC who feel it’ s
worth the drive. Go in for your family’s bagel
run or sit for a spell and enjoy delicious food
served by an effervescent staff that lov es to
feed its customers!
BEST LUNCH DEAL
PANERA BREAD
Multiple Locations
panerabread.com
When it comes to getting the most bang
for your buck in terms of q uality food, the
lunch deal at Panera Bread is unbeatable.
Warm up with one of Panera’s homestyle
soups, including chicken noodle or broccoli
cheddar. Feast on its famous sandwiches,
from the chipotle chicken avocado melt
to the toasted steak and white cheddar.
Panera’s You Pick Two option ev en lets you
pair up your favorite options; half soup,
half sandwich or half salad, along with your
side choice of chips, a fresh baguette or an
apple. This eatery is dedicated to serving
food without artificial preservativ es,
sweeteners or flavors, and its meals are
sourced from animals that are raised
humanely and sustainably. Make your
lunch plans at Panera and experience food
as it should be.
BEST LUNCHEONETTE
MAUREEN’S KITCHEN
108 Terry Rd, Smithtown
(631) 360-9227 www.facebook.com/
Maureens-Kitchen
There’s nothing quite like the coziness
and intimacy that comes with eating at
a luncheonette. Maureen’s Kitchen in
Smithtown not only offers delicious meals,
but also creates a welcoming and inviting
atmosphere that will make you feel right at
home. Maureen’s homey decor makes you feel
at ease as soon as you walk in, and once you
take a bite of their food you’ll really settle into
the comfortable vibes the eatery has to offer.
Maureen’s is the ideal spot to bring your
family and friends together for breakfast,
brunch and lunch alike, so you are covered
at any point in the day. Be sure to check out
the dessert counter so you can enjoy a treat
as you leave.
BEST MACARONI AND
CHEESE
ZORN’S OF BETHPAGE
4321 Hempstead Tpke, Bethpage
(516) 731-5500 zornsofbethpage.com
Since 1940, Zorn’s of Bethpage has crafted
food that tastes just like home to Long
Islanders. Nothing screams “homemade
comfort food” quite like the macaroni and
cheese at Zorn’s of Bethpage. This dish is
cheesy, creamy and decadent and is made
using four different types of cheese. It can be
eaten along with its famous skinless Southern
fried chicken or by itself if you choose.
What truly stands out is Zorn’s of Bethpage
commitment to using the freshest ingredients
and creating its iconic spices from scratch as
it was intended in the 1940s. Locals can count
on Zorn’s of Bethpage to deliver the one-two
punch of a tasty home made meal.
BEST MEATBALL
GRANDPA TONY’S
101 Althouse Ave, East Rockaway
(516) 799-8669 www.grandpatonysli.com
Meatballs are awesome. They are a dream
to eat and when you do make sure they are
the very best. The dish is king in this cozy
and popular Italian eatery where a legendary
favorite is Grandpa Tony’s Meatball Bomb.
The intense app comes with ricotta on top and
is served in a fresh bread bowl. Yum. Meatball
Parmigiana Hero or Meatball Salad - a bowl
feast of lettuce, onion, tomato, celery, and
meatballs with tomato sauce poured over -
among options at Grandpa Tony’s to enjoy
the popular dish. And what better way is there
to enjoy them outside of your own grandpa’s
kitchen than in a family-friendly eatery with
a warm ambiance, and the best crew ever, to
serve up the dish?
BEST MILKSHAKE
DOUGLAS & JAMES HOMEMADE ICE
CREAM (SWEAT TREATS ON THE WHARF)
405 Main St, Port Washington
(516) 708-1706
Nothing quenches your thirst and fills you up
quite like a cool milkshake on a hot summer
day. Located on scenic Main Street in Port
Washington, Sweet Treats on the Wharf offers
a wide selection of homemade ice cream,
frozen yogurt, and sorbet that can be easily
spun into a delicious milkshake. This shop
offers sugar free, kosher, lactose free and
gluten free options so there is something
for everyone in the family. This old school
ice cream shop has been a local favorite for
years because of their unique flavors and
neighborhood charm. If you’re looking for the
best milkshake the island has to offer, Sweet
Treats on the Wharf should be your only stop!
/panerabread.com
/www.vincentsclambar
/www.lobsterroll.com
/www.hilltopbagelcafe.com
/
/www.grandpatonysli.com
/BESTOFLONGISLAND.COM
/traderjoes.com
/www.hummusny.com
/www.hummusny.com
/panerabread.com
/uncleg.com
/nathansfamous.com
/www.vincentsclambar
/www.lobsterroll.com
/www.hilltopbagelcafe.com
/
/zornsofbethpage.com
/www.grandpatonysli.com