BESTOFLONGISLAND.COM WINNERS GUIDE BETHPAGE BEST OF LONG ISLAND 2021 17
BEST CRAFT BEER
BREWERY
PO’BOY BREWERY
200 Wilson St Unit E3, Port Jefferson Station
(631) 828-1131 www.poboybrewery.com
Po’Boy Brewery, located in Port Jefferson
Station, boasts a beautiful and cozy taproom and
welcoming staff. Most have called us a pleasant
and fun place to unwind and get together with
friends and family. We are one of the few places
in the country that is identified as a Brewery and
a Cidery! We rotate our taps regularly so that you
can experience a new flavor and style weekly!
The Tasting Room and Sour Patch have over 20
varieties of beer and cider to sample flights and
to order pints from. Growlers can be filled and
four-packs can be purchased for off-premise
consumption as well. Several food options to
choose from, special events and celebrations,
live music on specified nights, and we also offer
options of all varieties for hosting your special
event. It has been a pure joy to grow, expand and
define our unique, innovative approach to craft
beer and we have had a damn good time doing
it! Thank you for your support and for voting us
the BEST on Long Island! We will see you on the
other side of the bar!
BEST DISTILLERY
LIV VODKA
2182 Sound Ave, Baiting Hollow
(631) 630-9322 www.lispirits.com
It seems that craft distilleries may be the
next evolution of the craft beer boom that
has seen dozens of breweries pop up on Long
Island over the past decade. The distillers
at Long Island Spirits may not have quite
as much competition—there are still only a
handful of craft distilleries on the island—
but that doesn’t stop them from putting
their heart and soul into every sustainably
distilled bottle of LiV vodka. Owners and
childhood friends Rich Stabile and Dan
Pollicino use 100% locally grown russet
potatoes to triple distill the award-winning
gluten-free spirit. Mix it with orange juice,
tonic, club soda, or have it on the rocks. No
matter how it’s served, the spirit of Long
Island lives in every sip.
BEST HAPPY HOUR
SPIRO’S RESTAURANT & LOUNGE
4 Patchogue Dr, Rocky Point
(631) 744-4100 www.spiroslounge.com
At Spiro’s Restaurant & Lounge in Rocky Point,
happy hour happens twice a day! You read
that correctly — twice a day! It is known for
having Long Island’s top happy hour selection
for a reason. If you miss the first happy hour
which runs from 1 p.m.-6 p.m. Sunday through
Thursday or 1 p.m.-5 p.m. on Fridays and
Saturdays, you don’t have to wait until the next
day to take advantage of Spiro’s food and drink
specials. The second one runs until midnight
seven days a week. Once you go inside, all you
have to do is sit back, relax and enjoy a glass
or two of your favorite margarita or dark and
stormy cocktail.
BEST IRISH BAR
SHANDON COURT
115 E Main St, East Islip
(631) 581-5678 www.shandoncourt.net
At Shandon Court, the sweetest memories are
made to last a lifetime. From the moment you
step inside the premises, you’re immediately
transported to the pubs in Ireland where the
bartenders greet you with a wave and smile.
Shandon Court serves traditional favorites
such as shepard’s pie and corned beef and
cabbage along with pub food items. Top off your
experience with a pint or two of your favorite
Guinness or beer option while listening to live
music that’ll have you nodding your head and
tapping your fingers to the beat in no time.
Whether you’re enjoying a casual dinner or
booked a private event, the staff at Shandon
Court will help make every moment a happy one!
BEST LIQUOR STORE
WHEATLEY HILLS DISCOUNT WINE &
SPIRITS
193 Post Ave, Westbury
(516) 333-1110 www.
wheatleywineandspirits.com
Whether you want to throw a party, celebrate
an anniversary or need a nice bottle of red
to help you unwind after a long day at work,
Wheatley Hills Discount Wine & Spirits has got
you covered. The family-operated business has
been serving Long Island since 1994 and offers
an extensive selection of wines and spirits from
around the world. For a truly immersive shopping
experience, the staff — which has a combined 50
years in the wine and liquor industry — are happy
to help you find what you’re looking for and will
order any item they don’t normally carry in-store.
At Wheatley’s, you never have to worry about
missing out on the bottle of your choice!
BEST LOCAL WINERY
PINDAR VINEYARDS
37645 Main Rd Rte 25, Peconic
(631) 734-6200 www.pindar.net
At Pindar Vineyards, they know that a good wine
is like a great poem. Enjoying a glass can be an
uplifting experience, delighting the senses as it
satisfies the soul. Since Pindar’s founding four
decades ago, it has become one of Long Island’s
best-known wineries. Nestled on 500 acres on
the East End, it grows 17 varieties of grapes,
carefully crafting them into some 23 varietals
and proprietary blends. Each year, it produces
about 70,000 cases. But it’s never forgotten its
roots, nor its family tradition. At its flagship
vineyard, wine lovers can tour the production
facility, and taste great wines from the barrel!
BEST LONG ISLAND ICE TEA
MERCATO KITCHEN & COCKTAILS
4958 Merrick Rd, Massapequa Park
(516) 308-3582 www.mercatokitchen.com
The Long Island Iced Tea is a drink that is just as
complex as the drink’s namesake. With a blend
of vodka, tequila, light rum, triple sec, gin, and a
splash of cola, it takes a skilled bartender to create
the perfect mix. At Mercato Kitchen & Cocktails, the
staff have all the tools needed to create the perfec t
Long Island Iced Tea. The fully stocked bar has a
number of different alcohol brands so you could
make a custom Long Island Iced Tea blend by
swapping in some of your favorite labels. Be sure
to order one of Mercato’s delicious menu items to
munch on while you sip your Long Island Iced Tea.
BEST MARGARITA
BESITO MEXICAN - MULTIPLE LOCATIONS
Multiple Locations
besitomexican.com
Whether you’re looking to pair your tacos or
chips and homemade guac with the perfect
drink or just looking for the best selection of
margaritas around, Besito Mexican is the perfect
location – whichever one of its four locations on
the Island you choose. There are nine margarita
options on the menu to choose from, all with
fresh-squeezed lime, with or without salt on
the rim, including the Besito Patrón Margarita
made with Besito Barrel Select Patrón Reposado
Tequila, Cointreau, fresh pomegranate and
tangerine juices, as well as the frozen La Casa
Margarita. Other options include grapefruit,
mango and watermelon varieties. You can also
opt for the old standby: A Classic Margarita with
Premium Blanco Tequila and triple sec. Make
reservations online or by phone today!
BEST MARTINI
SPIRO’S RESTAURANT & LOUNGE
4 Patchogue Dr, Rocky Point
(631) 744-4100 www.spiroslounge.com
There’s nothing like a strong margarita after
a long day, and Spiro’s in Rocky Point makes
the best one in Long Island. Any bar can mix
gin with vermouth and plop and olive in it,
but Spiro’s has found the perfect blend of
ingredients that makes its martini known
far and wide. Spiros’ bartenders concoct a
drink that drives patron’s tastebuds wild
while giving them the perfect buzz. Once you
start feeling good, you’ll inevitably want to
pair your delightful beverage with some eats.
This acclaimed eatery has a menu that will
compliment your marg perfectly, featuring
apps like citrus tuna tartare and cherry
pepper calamari as well as entrees such as filet
mignon, rack of lamb, and stuffed salmon.
Come see what everyone is raving about; try
the perfect martini and more at Spiros!
BEST MOJITO
SPIRO’S RESTAURANT & LOUNGE
4 Patchogue Dr, Rocky Point
(631) 744-4100 www.spiroslounge.com
The perfect mojito is refreshing, packs the right
amount of mint and makes you want to lay on
a tropical beach. Mojitos are the specialty at
Spiro’s Restaurant & Lounge! You can never
go wrong with the original style, or you can
mix it up with its extensive mojito options
from blueberry to coconut to strawberry. This
beloved eatery offers a food menu that will
compliment your marg perfectly, featuring
apps like scallops wrapped in bacon and
shrimp pita along with entrees like as the 24oz
New York Strip and surf n turf. The fabulous
bartenders at Spiro’s are there to make your
mojito drinking experience as delicious and
pleasant as you’ll get on the island!
BEST NIGHTCLUB
MULCAHY’S PUB & CONCERT HALL
3232 Railroad Ave, Wantagh
(631) 783-7500 www.muls.com
If you’re looking for a hot spot for you and
your friends to enjoy a night on the town, you
have to swing by Mulcahy’s Pub & Concert
Hall in Wantagh. Mulcahy’s has shows playing
all year round, so you are guaranteed to have
the night of your life. The club boasts plenty
of room to roam plus a food and drink menu
to choose from when you come by and stop by
the pub. The dress code is smart casual, so you
don’t have to dress to the nines just to walk
through the door. At Mulcahy’s, the staff will
ensure that you have the time of your life.
BEST ROOFTOP BAR*
RHUM
13 East Main Street, Patchogue
(631) 569-5944 www.rhumpatchogue.com
Enjoy Island Time with a visit to the rooftop at
RHUM – delivering some of the most delectable
rum-based concoctions north of the Caribbean.
With Island-inspired cuisine, and the first rooftop
experience in Patchogue, you’ll want to get there
fast…then take it slow. Open daily year-round,
RHUM offers lunch and dinner daily, along
with family meals to go, weekly specials like
Taco Tuesday and Thursday, Margarita and
Mojito Monday, weekday happy hour, and more,
including its RHUM Punch Brunch every Saturday
and Sunday from 11am to 3pm and on- and off-site
catering options. Visit RhumPatchogue.com to
make a reservation on the rooftop!
BEST SIGNATURE COCKTAIL*
ALIBI SPEAKEASY & LOUNGE
230 Main St, Farmingdale
(516) 586-8622 alibifarmingdale.com
Come check out The Alibi Speakeasy & Lounge
in Farmingdale and prepare to step back in
time to the Prohibition Era, when relaxing
with a cocktail could get you locked up! The
Alibi is truly a unique way to spend a night
out, with its list of more than two dozen
Prohibition-themed signature cocktails such
as The Eliot Ness, a mix of light and dark rums
and passionfruit juice or The Lucky Luciano
made with bourbon, orange juice and vanilla.
Need some munchies? Check out the Alibi’s
eats from apps like pot stickers and mozzarella
sticks to homemade paninis, 10-inch bar
pizzas and decadent desserts like molten lava
cake or black and white cookies. You never
need an excuse to hang out at The Alibi!
BEST SINGLES SPOT
THE REFUGE
515 Broadhollow Rd, Melville
(631) 577-4444 refuge110.com
Long Island singles looking for a good time and
magnificent food and drink options can take
‘refuge’ at The Refuge in Melville. It offers a modern
twist on Italian and Latin cuisine with a nod to the
classics such as mussels and veal chops. Nothing
alleviates first date jitters and meet-cutes from
across the restaurant quite like a sharable meat and
cheese board filled with cured meats and artisanal
cheeses while sipping on a “sucker punch” cocktail
or a sangria. The Refuge is appropriately named
for its reputation for providing a comfortable
and engaging environment where you can eat
something good and simultaneously sip something
sinful whether you’re looking for a quick lunch,
relaxing dinner or indulging in brunch!
BEST SPORTS BAR
MILLER’S ALE HOUSE
Multiple Locations
millersalehouse.com
Looking for a great sports bar to watch the
game? With multiple locations throughout
Suffolk and Nassau counties, Miller’s Ale
House is the place where Long Islanders
gather to watch the big game, regardless of
which sports season is happening. Miller’s
offers a comfortable bar experience, making
it an ideal spot for you and your friends to
post up and watch. There are huge televisions
throughout the restaurant, so there’s not a
bad seat in the house. Plus, the bar is fully
stocked with lots of draft beer options (and
your necessary bar offerings, of course) to
whet your whistle while you are cheering for
your team. Be sure to order a plate of the bar’s
signature Zingers while you watch!
BEST WHISKEY BAR
ALIBI SPEAKEASY & LOUNGE
230 Main St, Farmingdale
(516) 586-8622 alibifarmingdale.com
Visit The Alibi Speakeasy & Lounge in
Farmingdale and prepare to step back in time to
the Prohibition Era, when grabbing a whiskey
was more than a way to blow off steam after
work...it could get you a few days in jail! The
Alibi is a unique way to spend a night out, with
its list of more than eight top-shelf whiskeys such
as Jameson, Jack Daniels, Fireball Cinnamon
Whiskey or Dunsmore Irish Whiskey. If you need
some munchies to go with those great whiskeys,
check out the Alibi’s eats from apps like pot
stickers and mozzarella sticks to homemade
paninis, 10-inch bar pizzas and decadent desserts
like molten lava cake or black and white cookies.
You never need an excuse to hang out at The Alibi.
BEST WINE BAR OR CELLAR
IL POZZO WINE BAR & KITCHEN
46 Atlantic Ave, Lynbrook
(516) 596-7870 www.ilpozzowinebar.com
A casual Wine Bar and Kitchen in walking
distance from the railroad in lovely Lynbrook
Village you may go in for a glass of homemade
sangria or a classic wine to pair with American
cuisine. The vibe here is intimate and casual,
a gem in town whose owner is attentive and
makes sure his establishment is laid back and
relaxing. Large windows allow you to watch
walkers-by outside and you can share small
bites here or order a larger meal and share
that too if you like. The lounge has a cozy area
with a couch and you can order from a sturdy
menu here that includes Fried Artichokes and
Three-Cheese Shells, Prime NY Steak and
Lamb burger among savory options.
/www.spiroslounge.com
/www.lispirits.com
/www.spiroslounge.com
/www.shandoncourt.net
/www.wheatleywineandspirits.com
/www.wheatleywineandspirits.com
/www.pindar.net
/www.mercatokitchen.com
/www.spiroslounge.com
/www.spiroslounge.com
/www.muls.com
/www.rhumpatchogue.com
/www.ilpozzowinebar.com
/BESTOFLONGISLAND.COM
/www.poboybrewery.com
/www.lispirits.com
/www.poboybrewery.com
/www.spiroslounge.com
/www.spiroslounge.com
/www.shandoncourt.net
/wheatleywineandspirits.com
/www.pindar.net
/www.mercatokitchen.com
/besitomexican.com
/www.muls.com
/www.rhumpatchogue.com
/RhumPatchogue.com
/alibifarmingdale.com
/alibifarmingdale.com
/refuge110.com
/millersalehouse.com
/work...it
/www.ilpozzowinebar.com