Legally Speaking By: Scott Baron, Attorney at Law WATER ON MY BOAT Q: On the swim platform of my boat, while it was docked at a marina, I slipped on some funny-colored water. It turned out to be overflow water from an artesian well system. The water had been discharged by a pipe, right onto my boat. I suppose I should sue the owner of the marina. Should I also sue the contractor that constructed the artesian well system? What about the subcontractor that installed the pipe? A: The contractor will argue, “Don’t sue us. Sue the subcontractor.” The contractor will contend that it did not control the subcontractor’s work. One who employs an independent contractor has no right to control the manner in which the work is to be done. The risk of loss is more sensibly placed on the independent contractor. Control is the critical factor. The owner of the marina will argue that the condition of the water flowing from the pipe was not inherently dangerous. Indeed, it was open and obvious. Granted, the owner had a duty to maintain the marina in a reasonably safe condition. Nevertheless, it had no duty to protect or warn against an open and obvious condition, which as a matter of law was not inherently dangerous. The owner may also argue that you had assumed a risk inherent in the recreational activity of boating. Whether the slippery water was open and obvious cannot be divorced from the surrounding circumstances. Was the condition in any way obscured? For some acceptable reason, were you distracted? The owner may call this water a condition that was ordinarily apparent to a person making reasonable use of his senses. In the hands of your attorney, let us hope the jury will call the water a trap for the unwary. Learn from the best musicians in New York Inquire about our kids group singing classes! Serving Long Island City for 10 years 44-02 23rd St, Suite #203 (2nd fl) 917-548-3598 Professional faculty from: Juilliard · Mannes · Berklee · & more! WINNER of the 2013 THE QUEENS QueensCourier.com Serving the Long Island City Area For 17 Years! “LI# B01506” 23-03 Astoria Blvd. • Astoria • 718.204.5861 MINI VANS AVAILABLE ASK FOR PRICING LAGUARDIA NOW $2 OFF Expires 1/31/15 www.queenscourier.com I LIC COURIER I DECEMBER 2014 39 Corporate Accounts Welcome Luxury Car & Limousine Service Door To Door • 24 Hours • Se Habla Español $2 OFF Any Ride To Manhattan/Queens Minimum $20 Not to be combined with any other offer NEWARK NOW $5 OFF Expires 1/31/15 KENNEDY NOW $3 OFF Expires 1/31/15 WITH COUPON ONLY WITH COUPON ONLY WITH COUPON ONLY Advertorial The law responds to changed conditions; exceptions and variations abound. Here, the information is general; always seek out competent counsel This article shall not be construed as legal advice. Copyright © 2014 Scott Baron & Associates, P.C. All rights reserved. 159-49 Cross Bay Boulevard, Howard Beach, New York 11414 1750 Central Park Ave, Yonkers, NY 10710 718-738-9800, 914-337-9800, 1-866-927-4878 Voice · Piano · Violin · Cello · Guitar · Bass Clarinet · Saxophone · Drums · Harp Flute · Trumpet · Vibraphone Long Island City Academy Music of www.licmusicacademy.com
LIC122014
To see the actual publication please follow the link above