BEST MILKSHAKE
DOUGLAS & JAMES HOMEMADE
ICE CREAM (SWEET TREATS
ON THE WHARF)
405 Main St #1, Port Washington
(516) 708-1706
Nothing quenches your thirst and fills you up
quite like a cool milkshake on a hot summer
day. Located on scenic Main Street in Port
Washington, Sweet Treats on the Wharf offers
a wide selection of homemade ice cream, frozen
yogurt, and sorbet that can be easily spun into a
delicious milkshake. This old school ice cream
shop has been a local favorite for years because
of their unique flavors and neighborhood charm,
and their milkshake can’t be beat. The best part?
After you get your shake, you can enjoy it while
walking along the shoreline. Is it summer yet?
BEST MILKSHAKE
(NATIONAL
WINNER)
SHAKE SHACK
Multiple Locations
shakeshack.com
Everyone craves a good old milkshake every
once in a while. Maybe you want to dip your fries
in something sweet. Or perhaps, you’re looking
to get a quick dessert. Whatever the decision,
Shake Shack more than delivers on its promise
to provide their loyal customers with out-ofthis
world flavors that’ll satisfy that sweet tooth.
From classic favorites like vanilla, strawberry
and chocolate to seasonal concoctions like red
velvet, frozen hot chocolate and cookie butter,
it’s no surprise why people consistently wait in
long lines or order for pickup to get a hold of one
of their decadent shakes!
BEST MUSSELS
POPEI’S CLAM BAR
451 Middle Country Rd, Coram
(631) 696-4029 popeisclambaronline.com
Crack em open and savor what’s inside — the
best mussels on the Long Island are found at
none other than Popei’s Clam Bar. Since 1991,
Popei’s has been the top spot on the isle for
delicious seafood, and their savory mussels
continue to keep customers coming back for
more. Popei’s casual but vibrant atmosphere
makes enjoying the shelled, chewy delights all
the more fun. In the summer, patrons can enjoy
their mussels with great drinks and live music at
the outdoor Tiki bar, and in the colder seasons,
the feast continues indoors. Popei’s is known for
their generous portions, so come hungry!
BEST NACHOS
DIRTY TACO AND
TEQUILA–WANTAGH
3261 Merrick Rd, Wantagh
(516) 785-5300 dirtytacoandtequila.com
One of the quintessential appetizers for a group
to enjoy on a night out is a plate of nachos.
Wantagh’s Dirty Taco and Tequila serves up
the best nachos that you can enjoy at any time.
Dirty Taco and Tequila puts a unique spin on
their nachos–called “Asian Style Nachos,” their
crispy tortilla chips are topped with pulled
Korean short ribs, mung bean sprouts, cheddar
cheese, queso fresco, crispy peanuts, scallions
and chillies, and is topped with a drizzle of
peanut sauce. Is your mouth watering yet? Don’t
forget to try their “Loaded Tatchos”–crispy tater
tots topped with spicy queso, red onion, pico de
gallo, jalapeno and guacamole.
BEST OFF PREMISE
CATERER
CHUBS MEATS
2598 Rte 112, Medford
(631) 475-9191 chubsmeats112.com
If you’re hosting a big party or event and need
some top-notch catering to serve to your guests,
you have to go to Chub Meats. From sliders
to salads and heros and platters, Chub Meats
has a huge selection of items so you can truly
customize the menu to suit your needs. Chub
Meats has a variety of full meals to choose from,
complete with proteins, pastas, vegetables and
other side dishes, plus a number of desserts to
polish off the meal with. The knowledgeable
staff at Chubs Meats will guide you in the right
direction to ensure your event is a success.
Tastings are available upon request. Plus, Chubs
Meats offers free local delivery and setup for
your event.
BEST ORGANIC
EATERY
ORGANIC KRUSH
Amagansett, Plainview, Rockville Centre,
Roseland, and Woodbury.
organickrush.com
Organic Krush is very popular among those
who enjoy a healthy organic meal or drink.
Welcoming the community through its doors
since 2015, Organic Krush is your trusted source
of delicious, organic food and cold-pressed
juices. They are committed to serving food that
is free of pesticides, GMOs, hormones and fake
ingredients. Organic Krush is ready to be part of
your wellness story, believing that healthy eating
habits are just the start of your well-being!
BEST PANCAKES
CJ’S COFFEE SHOP
225 N Long Beach Rd, Rockville Centre
(516) 766-9107 cjscoffeeshop.com
Nothing satisfies a sweet tooth in the morning —
or any pretty much any time of the day— more
than pancakes, and for Long Island residents,
CJ’s Coffee Shop has perfected the craft of
creating a fluffy meal dedicated to make your
stomach happy. Whether you’re in the mood for
a classic buttermilk stack, looking to splurge on
chocolate chip or mix it up with a with a hint of
peanut butter on top, every order comes with a
savory side of turkey sausage, bacon, ham and
coffee or tea so that you can start your day on
the right foot!
BEST PANCAKES
(NATIONAL
WINNER)
IHOP
Multiple Locations
ihop.com
At IHOP, you can never go wrong with ordering
a stack of pancakes. From their signature fluffy
buttermilk pancakes to stacks that pack a heavy
flavor profile from strawberry to birthday cake
to New York Cheesecake, they’re guaranteed to
satisfy your stomach. You can enjoy them on
their own, or pair it with a side of bacon, eggs or
sausage with a hot cup of coffee. Start your day,
afternoon or night off right with a delicious stack
of flapjacks!
BEST PASTRAMI
SANDWICH
BEN’S KOSHER DELICATESSEN
RESTAURANT & CATERERS
Multiple Locations
(800) 344-BENS bensdeli.net
Ben’s Deli puts the “heart” into a hearty meal.
Since 1972, they have served as Long Island’s
premier Kosher delicatessen, stacking the tallest,
meatiest pastrami sandwich around. Ben’s
overstuffed sandwiches are a melt-in-yourmouth
treat between two slices of rye. If you’re
brave, you’ll take it all in one bite, but you’ll
likely want to take a few slices home for later.
Complete your meal with fresh-cut coleslaw and
crunchy pickles and you’re in business! Ben’s
offers pick up, dine in, and catering, so you can
enjoy their delectable delights whether you’re
staying a while or elsewhere. For the top cuts of
pastrami on the island, stroll into Ben’s!
BEST PICKLE
THE PICKLE PEOPLE
611 Woodfield Rd, West Hempstead
(516) 481-5350 mypicklepeople.com
The Pickle People have been in the pickle
business for over 40 years. Many remember
their start inside Shoppers Village in 1980. They
remain still today in West Hempstead, and are
inside the Western Beef supermarket at 611
Woodfield Rd. In addition to the shop which is
open year round, they also attend street fairs and
festivals across Long Island from April thru Nov.
Some of their renowned recipes include Cajun,
Full Sour, New Green, Atomic Hot & Spicy, Bread
& Butter, Sweet Ginger, Horseradish, Hot-Shots,
& Mustard pickles just to name a few! The
company also offers Sauerkraut, Sweet Peppers,
Pickled Tomatoes, and Onions. Pickle fans can
also purchase tart & tangy naturally fermented
pickle brine by the quart. All products are under
Kashrut Supervision, Kosher and Pareve.
BEST PIZZA
GRANDPA TONY’S
101 Althouse Ave, East Rockaway
(516) 799-8669 grandpatonysli.com
Find yourself in old-world Italy with a taste of the
cuisine brought over by immigrants in the late
1800’s with hearty portions and fresh ingredients
at Grandpa Tony’s Wood Fired Pizza in East
Rockaway. They offer food specials and events
throughout the week including pasta night,
seasonal Saturday, live music and ladies night.
Fill up your Sunday with a delicious midday
brunch and their award-winning pizza alla vodka
as you enjoy the view of the waterfront. Walk-ins
are welcome but reservations are recommended
as they fill up to capacity.
BEST RIBS
SMOKIN AL’S
4847 Merrick Rd, Massapequa Park
(516) 799-4900 smokinals.com
For the most succulent ribs this side of the
Northeast, look no further than Smokin Al’s in
Massapequa Park. Smokin Al himself has made
it his mission to serve barbecued ribs, traveling
through the Southern U.S. to perfect the art
of barbecuing. Their signature Specialty Baby
Backs are slowly smoked over six hours and then
covered in three BBQ sauces of your choice. If
St. Louis Ribs are more your speed, their St.
Louie Grand Backs are smoked for seven hours
until the pork is falling right off the bone. If
that’s not enough, their monstrous Black Angus
Beef Bones is sure to please you! Whatever
your preference, Smokin’ Al’s seeks to make
sure the customers have a satisfying meal and a
wonderful experience.
BEST RICE BALL
PIZZATINI
185 Henry St, Hempstead
(516) 280-8226 pizzatini.com
Not in the mood for a specialty pizza pie? Not a
problem. At Pizzatini in West Hempstead, the
possibilities to enjoy a meal are endless — and
that especially includes the Arancini, better
known as rice balls. This Italian cuisine staple
typically consists of risotto, mozzarella, peas,
sauce, bread crumbs and prosciutto. But at
Pizzatini, this dish is served with a twist. As soon
as you take a bite, you’ll instantly get a taste of
their perfectly cooked ground beef that’s been
carefully prepared by their cooks. Enlighten
your senses, and your stomach with the best rice
ball dish on the island!
BEST RICE PUDDING
LUCKY LOU’S GOURMET PUDDING
4603 Middle Country Rd, Calverton
(631) 672-1932 luckylousinc.com
The perfect bite of a rice pudding dish evokes
feelings of warmth, sweetness and comfort.
Lucky Lou’s Gourmet Pudding elevates the
dessert to a higher level. Their rice pudding
40 BETHPAGE BEST OF LONG ISLAND 2020 WINNERS GUIDE BESTOFLONGISLAND.COM
is made to perfection and is topped with just
enough cinnamon that will make you want to
devour it from the cup and skip the utensils.
Their rice grains are sourced from farms
throughout the United States and the milk
comes from grass fed cows so that you can
receive the highest quality possible in your
dessert. Lucky Lou’s Gourmet Pudding is
available in stores throughout Long Island so
don’t miss out on the chance to taste the best!
BEST SALAD
GREENWAY DELI
110 Broadway, Greenlawn
(631) 754-9574 greenwaydeli.com
Salads are the perfect combination of healthful,
light and tasty. If you’re up for the best salad on
the island, mix it up at Greenway Deli! Chicken,
tuna, egg or classic — no matter what concoction
you’re craving, Greenway has it in their window
display. Throw it over a bed of lettuce, mix it with
fresh veggies and top it off with your choice of
dressing; put it in a wrap or stuff it between two
loaves of bread sandwiches — there are countless
ways to enjoy the rich mix of flavors. Getting your
salad from just any deli can be a “toss up”. For a
truly exquisite blend, choose Greenway Deli!
BEST SALAD
(NATIONAL
WINNER)
PANERA BREAD
Multiple Locations
panerabread.com
If you can make people actually enjoy eating a
salad, you deserve the upmost praise. Panera
never fails to satisfy for any occasion or meal.
It’s a great place to have a girls-day-out and
enjoy their popular salad which just so happens
to be the best in Long Island! Panera offers a
satisfying atmosphere where you can enjoy
your meal in a hushed ambiance of happiness.
When it comes to catering and online ordering,
Panera is fabulously keeping up with the latest
trends. It’s hard to think of a better place to get a
deliciously crisp salad that truly satisfies.
BEST SANDWICH
DEAL
MAC’S COUNTRYSIDE
DELI & CATERING
61 Half Mile Rd, Middle Island
(631) 448-8955 macscountrysidedeli.com
Getting a great sandwich deal without breaking
the bank on Long Island is as good as it gets
for the hungry person. At Mac’s Countryside
Deli & Catering, you can either build your own
mouthwatering sandwich or choose from one
of their many options from The Oldman — a
twist on the Italian club sandwich to the Tommy
Pastrami which features sauerkraut and Russian
dressing. Their signature sandwiches are served
on a generous 12-inch hero so that you can save
a piece for the drive home. At Mac’s Countryside
Deli, you are guaranteed that your sandwich
experience is taken to a higher level!
BEST SAUSAGE AND
PEPPERS SANDWICH
VITO’S RISTORANTE & PIZZERIA
91 Forest Ave, Glen Cove
(516) 759-1366 vitospizzany.com
What can be better than a hero full of Italian
sausage, peppers and onions? If you’re looking
for the best sausage and peppers sandwich
on Long Island, look no further than Vito’s
Ristorante. The eatery opened the doors to
their first pizzeria in 1982 on Avenue L in
Canarsie which quickly became a staple in the
community. Ten years of service, two pizzerias,
and three kids later, they moved the family out
to Long Island where they opened their third
location. This is where their son began to learn
the trade, studying his father’s every move. For
the best in sausage and peppers, and all things
Italian, check out Vito’s Ristorante today.
/grandpatonysli.com
/popeisclambaronline.com
/dirtytacoandtequila.com
/chubsmeats112.com
/organickrush.com
/cjscoffeeshop.com
/ihop.com
/bensdeli.net
/mypicklepeople.com
/shakeshack.com
/smokinals.com
/pizzatini.com
/luckylousinc.com
/BESTOFLONGISLAND.COM
/greenwaydeli.com
/panerabread.com
/macscountrysidedeli.com
/vitospizzany.com
