ISLAMAPHOBIA AT SEA 
 Complaint accuses NYC Ferry staffers of refusing Muslim families because of ‘security issue’ 
 BY KEVIN DUGGAN 
 Crew  aboard  a  city  ferry  
 forbid a group of Muslim families  
 from boarding a Brooklynbound  
 boat last month because  
 they posed a “security issue,”  
 according to an attorney for the  
 jilted passengers. 
 “We believe that it was because  
 of who they were and  
 how they looked, there’s nothing  
 else that explains that this  
 group — three mothers and 11  
 children — were labelled a security  
 issue,” said Ahmed Mohamed, 
   an  attorney  with  the  
 the Muslim civil rights group  
 the Council on American-Islamic  
 Relations. 
 The  families  fi led a complaint  
 on Wednesday with the  
 city’s Commission on Human  
 Rights in an effort to spark an  
 investigation into the incident.   
 The three mothers, two infants, 
  four young boys, and  
 two young girls — who remain  
 anonymous in the complaint —  
 were waiting to board a Kings  
 County-bound watercraft from  
 Manhattan’s Pier 11, when  
 two crew members whispered  
 something to each other, before  
 informing the families that  
 boat security had decided to  
 deny their passage, according  
 to the complaint.  
 The employees escorted the  
 distraught mothers to security  
 staffers, while the ferry’s passengers  
 35 YEARS OF EXCELLENT SERVICE 
 Large Selection of 
 Vacuums, Sewing Machine, Hand Vacs, Air Conditioners, Appliances,  
 Austin Air Purifi ers 
 Guaranteed Lowest Prices in Brooklyn! 
 MR. VACUUM COUPON 
 REPAIR ANY VACUUM  
 OR SEWING MACHINE 
 $1495 
 + PARTS 
 + TAX 
 10/31/19. 
 WITH COUPON ONLY. EXPIRES 04/18. 
 APPROVED                  &                 DEALER 
 COURIER L 38     IFE, OCTOBER 25-31, 2019 
 watched the scene unfold  
 — but the head of the pier’s  
 security was confused about  
 his colleagues’ claims of security  
 issues, according to the  
 document.  
 The complaint goes on to  
 accuse another ferryboat employee  
 of raising her voice to  
 the families in a “rude” and  
 “unprofessional” way.  
 That employee informed the  
 families that they were being  
 denied service because their  
 kids had allegedly stood on  
 their seats aboard a previous  
 ferry ride during a trip from  
 Brooklyn to Manhattan earlier  
 that day. 
 One of the women submitted  
 a complaint to ferry operator  
 Hornblower as well, and the  
 company later explained the  
 incident as a “misunderstanding” 
  and offered to reimburse  
 their fare.  
 But the families remain unsatisfi  
 ed and fi led the complaint  
 to ensure that future passengers  
 don’t experience the same type  
 of discrimination, according to  
 Mohamed, who demanded that  
 the Economic Development  
 Corporation — the city’s business  
 boosting arm which manages  
 the ferry system — better  
 train its employees. 
 “The most important thing  
 is that we want to empathize is  
 to provide people of fair service  
 that’s free of discrimination,”  
 he said. “Any type of resolution  
 requires some kind of training,  
 and that the staff are not using  
 their authority to traumatize or  
 humiliate people.”  
 A spokesman for the agency  
 said they are investigating the  
 incident to make sure no rider  
 is discriminated against based  
 on their background. 
 “We are aware of the complaint  
 and are currently investigating  
 the incident. NYCEDC  
 takes these matters seriously,  
 and is committed to ensuring  
 that  no  person  is  denied  services  
 based on race, color, national  
 origin, age, sex, religion,  
 gender identity or disability,”  
 said Christian Ficara in an  
 emailed statement. 
 Muslim families claim crew aboard a NYC Ferry gave them the boot over security concerns.  
  
  
  
 8705 5 
  
 WWW.MRVACUUMSTORES.COM 
 DONATE YOUR CAR  
 Wheels For Wishes 
 benefiting  
 Make-A-Wish®  
 Metro New York 
 * 100% Tax Deductible                                                             
 * Free Vehicle Pickup ANYWHERE                                 
 * We Accept Most Vehicles Running or Not  
 * We Also Accept Boats, Motorcycles & RVs 
 WheelsForWishes.org 
 * Car Donation Foundation d/b/a Wheels For Wishes. To learn more about our programs or  
 Call:(917)336-1254 
 	
	
 
 ■ 
 Brooklyn’s Premier Entertainment Guide 
 For more hyper-local Brooklyn news on your computer,  
 smartphone, or iPad, visit BrooklynPaper.com 
 
				
/WWW.MRVACUUMSTORES.COM
		/WheelsForWishes.org
		/BrooklynPaper.com