BESTOFBK.COM • WINNERS GUIDE • DIME BEST OF BROOKLYN 2020 21
BEST COOKIES
COOKIE HOUSE
5100 Kings Plz Mall Brooklyn
(718) 258-6842 - www.kingsplazaonline.com
Tucked away in a booth at the King’s Plaza
Mall, you might think that Cookie House could
be easy to miss. But from the moment you
open the doors into King’s plaza Mall, that
intoxicating scent of sweet warm cookies finds
you and beckons you towards its source--You
can’t miss it! Cookie House’s cookies are so
good that you may not ever get around to trying
their other treats, like pretzels or muffins, but
this would be a mistake! Cookie House is also
serving up some of the best pretzels you can get
your hands on outside of Philly!
BEST CUPCAKES
SUGAR COATED BAKERY
1078 65th Street, Brooklyn
(718) 259-9885 - www.sugarcoatedny.com
Sugar Coated Bakery is the place to get the cake
or cupcakes you’ve been thinking about for that
special day or event. Their goods are as sweet
as their name. They can make whatever you’re
looking for to liven up whatever you need.
Talented bakers making custom cakes that are
sure to impress and sure to be as delicious as
they are beautiful to look at. They allow you to
pick from a wealth of designs on their website
and place your custom order. Soon, you’ll have
a delicious cake that you’ll almost hate spoiling,
it looks so good. But it tastes just as sweet.
BEST DESSERT
AMPLE HILLS CREAMERY
305 Nevins St, Brooklyn
(347) 725-4061 - www.amplehills.com
Kids love ice cream and there’s no better place
to take the kids for a “sundae” treat than Ample
Hills Creamery. Founded in the spring of 2011 by
married couple Brian Smith and Jackie Cuscuna,
they were at fi rst terrifi ed that no one would
show up — but were wildly unprepared when
they did. In just four days, Brian and Jackie
sold out of ice cream! They hadn’t prepared
to be so popular; to churn enough ice cream
for the never-ending line, they had to close.
While Ample Hills has grown a lot since those
days, Brian and Jackie are still balancing it all:
imagining new fl avors, managing the day-to-day
operations and taking care of their children.
BEST DONUT
MIKE’S DONUTS
6822 5th Ave, Brooklyn
(718) 745-6980 - www.mikesdonuts.com
Forget Dunkin Donuts and Krispy Kreme, they
cannot compete with Mike’s taste of a true,
authentic donut. Mike’s Donut Shop has been
stuffing donuts since 1976. Mike is still there
and so is his wife, Christina. Mike has trained
his son Gus and son-in-law John to bring the
fresh donut experience to the people of Bay
Ridge, Brooklyn. Mike’s Donut Shop bakes
everything on the premises twice a day. There
are around 35 mouth watering types of donuts.
Some include the jelly and cream, glazed,
marble cruller, and the Boston cream. Because
the donuts are made fresh daily, they are light,
soft, and a bit chewy with just the right amount
of sugar to satisfy any sweet tooth.
BEST DUMPLINGS
KATHY’S DUMPLINGS
7924 3rd Ave, Brooklyn
(718) 833-7000 - www.kathysdumplings.com
Kathy’s Dumplings offers delicious dining,
takeout and delivery to Brooklyn. Kathy’s
Dumplings is a cornerstone in the Brooklyn
community and has been recognized for its
outstanding Chinese cuisine, excellent service
and friendly staff. Their Chinese restaurant is
known for its modern interpretation of classic
dishes and its insistence on only using high
quality fresh ingredients. The dumplings come
pan fried, boiled or steamed. Kathy’s Dumplings
serves its community with pride and guarantees
that every customer leaves with a smile on their
face. Located conveniently on 3rd Ave., they love
to serve people from across the borough and the
rest of New York City.
BEST FALAFEL
KARAM RESTAURANT
8519 4th Ave, Brooklyn
(718) 745-5227
If you’re looking for delicious Middle Eastern
cuisine, look no further than Karam Restaurant.
As soon as you step foot into the quaint restaurant,
you feel as though you’ve transported to the Middle
East, thanks to their warm tones and authentic
decorations in their seating area. But Karam
Restaurant is also the perfect place to catch a
quick bite and go. Their menu offers customers a
wide selection of dishes, including options that are
perfect for vegan and vegetarian diets. From their
halal to their inventive fl atbread pizzas, there’s
a little bit of everything in store. Their delicious
falafels — which are crispy on the outside and goey
on the inside and made with fresh ingredients —
also stand out as a fan-favorite.
BEST FOOD CO-OP
SAHADI’S
187 Atlantic Ave, Brooklyn
(718) 624-4550
Originally from Lebanon, the Sahadi family
opened shop in Manhattan in 1898. Since
taking the business to Atlantic Avenue in 1948,
the Middle-Eastern specialty food store has
become an iconic Brooklyn tradition. Shoppers
cross borough and state lines for Sahadi’s
hummus, baba ghanoush, spices and dried
fruits, authentic prepared food and baked
goods. Take a ticket and wait for service at
the deli, whose most popular dishes include
tabbouleh, lentils and onions, moussaka and
falafel. And there’s more! This past summer
the Sahadi family expanded into Industry City,
opening a second location that offers sit-down
service. Constantly alive with the bustle of its
loyal customers, Sahadi’s legendary rein is sure
to endure.
BEST FOOD TRUCK
TACOS EL BRONCO
4324 4th Ave, Brooklyn
(718) 788-2229
In a neighborhood well-known for its Mexican
food, it’s hard to stand out — but Tacos El Bronco
and their food truck does just that. Brooklynites
looking for fl avor-packed tacos seek out Taco El
Bronco for their straightforward menu, consisting
of several different meat-based fi llings, such as
roast pork, chicken, veal head, beef tongue, or
chorizo sausage. Their Fourth Avenue restaurant
offers a more comprehensive menu, including
tostadas, burritos, burgers, and snacks, so make
sure to check out both!
BEST FOOD VENDOR
ISABELLA’S CREATIONS
6624 11th Ave, Brooklyn
(347) 464-8845 -
www.isabellascreations.com
Since establishing Isabella’s Creations in March
2010, the staff feels that every day is a gift! They
truly enjoy every moment and welcome every
new challenge. Isabella’s Creations fi nds personal
joy to see the expressions on the customers face
when they see the cake or creation made for
them, and knowing that they’ve helped in a small
way to make their day a bit more special. They
take great pride in making one-of-a-kind cakes
and goodies at affordable prices so that everyone
can have their dream cake and eat it too!
Isabella’s also provide catering services offering
the best in Italian, American and Spanish
cuisine. They want to ensure that every customer
is satisfi ed!
BEST FRIED CHICKEN
BUTTERMILK CHANNEL
524 Court St, Brooklyn
(718) 852-8490 -
www.buttermilkchannelnyc.com
You won’t fi nd a better piece of fried chicken in
all of Brooklyn than at the appropriately named
Buttermilk Channel. This quaint eatery offers
offering a hearty American comfort food menu
and a popular weekend brunch. Buttermilk
Channel is a true Brooklyn neighborhood hang
serving some of the best fried chicken in town.
You can have an amazing dinner and incredible
evening or just brunch. The service is as warm
and friendly as the ambiance. A unique treasure
available to the community in Brooklyn,
Buttermilk Channel will entertain your taste buds
with chicken so good, it’ll make you forget about
all the chain fried chicken you’ve ever eaten.
BEST GOURMET FOOD
STORE
SAHADI’S
187 Atlantic Ave, Brooklyn
(917) 765-3875
Originally from Lebanon, the Sahadi family
opened shop in Manhattan in 1898. Since
taking the business to Atlantic Avenue in 1948,
the Middle-Eastern specialty food store has
become an iconic Brooklyn tradition. Shoppers
cross borough and state lines for Sahadi’s
hummus, baba ganoush, spices and dried
fruits, authentic prepared food and baked
goods. You can find anything at the shop,
which boasts an impressive bulk foods section,
deli, bakery, cheese department, and coffee
stand. And there’s more! This past summer
the Sahadi family expanded into Industry City,
opening a second location that offers sit-down
service. Constantly alive with the bustle of its
loyal customers, Sahadi’s legendary rein is sure
to endure.
BEST GYRO
SOMETHINGREEK
7616 Third Ave, Brooklyn
(718) 748-8200 -
www.somethingreekonline.com
Fresh ingredients and traditional flavors
are what makes the gyros at Somethingreek
something special for all who enjoy them.
They prepare and marinate their gyros and
souvlaki to taste the same as those which the
family ate at home and in Greece. From the
chicken and pork gyros down to the tzatziki
and hummus, everything is made in house
using quality ingredients. They employ fulltime
onsite butchers to prepare the meats,
and Mama herself makes their dinner specials
daily using her own recipes that they, her five
children, have been eating for as long as they
can remember.
BEST HEALTH FOOD
STORE
APPLETREE NATURAL MARKET
7613 3rd Ave, Brooklyn
(718) 745-5776
Natural and organic foods and supplements…
Good things for your body and soul. Appletree
Natural Market is your local stop for things
that will keep you healthy while tasting great.
Appletree’s staff are knowledgeable about
their stock and if they are out of stock on
something they will very often order more or
order an item for you if their supplier carries
it. They have every rare, strange, hard to find
ingredients that you had no idea you needed
or were even looking for. Great variety of
gluten-free and vegan items for your pantry.
Appletree is your friend. It’s the mom-and-pop
alternative to the big health food chains. At
Appletree, they care as much as you do about
what you put into your body.
FOOD
/BESTOFBK.COM
/www.sugarcoatedny.com
/www.amplehills.com
/www.mikesdonuts.com
/www.kathysdumplings.com
/www.isabellascreations.com
/www.buttermilkchannelnyc.com
/www.somethingreekonline.com
/www.kingsplazaonline.com
/www.kingsplazaonline.com
/www.sugarcoatedny.com
/www.amplehills.com
/www.mikesdonuts.com
/www.kathysdumplings.com
/www.isabellascreations.com
/www.buttermilkchannelnyc.com
/www.somethingreekonline.com